The Kelley House

Beautifully done hotel. Absolutely stunning decor! The rooms are modern and spacious. Love the height of the ceilings. The lobby is cozy, bright, and warm. Great amenities too. Most of the staff were AMAZING. The only reason I wouldn’t come back was because my family did not appreciate manager Rebecca (with the curly hair) questioning if we were guests of the hotel after she walked into the pool/gym area and saw us sitting in one of the cabanas. We were the only ones questioned while there were a few other families there. It was our last day and we (my parents and I) didn’t get to chill by the pool the few days prior because we were running around the island as well as visiting Nantucket, so I figured we can sit down, chat, and relax before checking out. The pool attendant was super lovely and then Rebecca came in. She pulled the pool attendant to the side, a few feet away from us, and asked her about us. The pool attendant came straight to us afterwards and asked “are you guests of the hotel” I said yes. She then asked for the room # which I gave. Then asked questions about our schedule and whether or not we were planning to come back to the pool (maybe because guests might and trespassers won’t?) The pool attendant was still lovely throughout, & she directly reported everything to Rebecca, who then left. We felt uncomfortable so we went to our room and waited there until checkout. I watched other guests arrive (some in swimwear, some not) & not get questioned. Disappointing

The hotel is cute. Yet for $800 a night we have to request our room to be made daily. And one day they missed. Not what you would expect for this price. Lots of kids behaving noisily. Twice he had to call the front desk to quiet neighbours down. In one instance our next door neighbour try to break in through the door (they were adjoining rooms). He was obviously drunk. Staff is great, but everything is bare bones. I was charged for stuff i really did order and it took a while to get the money back, which is annoying. Most rooms don't have views, so don't be fooled by pics on hotels.com. The location is lovely and parking was relatively easy. For that money we will not come back but trade up to the Harborview Hotel o the Charlotte in.

Amazing!!! The rooms were beautiful and very clean! The beds were super comfortable! The pool and other amenities were all were all clean and well cared for! The staff was incredibly friendly, thoughtful, and helpful, and even gave us toys for our children to play with (and keep!) for the pool and beach! The location is perfect, and it was fun to be in the middle of Edgartown! The Kelley House is our new favorite place to stay, and we can't wait to go back!